UN Inquiry Fails Before It Begins – Paul Fry

The UN should be congratulated on setting up an official inquiry into the human rights violations perpetrated by the Sri Lankan government during the country’s civil war. Granted, that inquiry is coming rather late (about five years late), is horribly undermanned (only twelve official staff members), and is restricted to only ten months in which to complete its inquiry. And of course, it will only look at the last years of the civil war in Sri Lanka which ended in 2009, turning a blind eye to all of the ongoing human rights violations in the country today.

While the UN has done a phenomenal job at developing international human rights norms since its inception, it has to see the world clearly to act appropriately. As Bertrand Ramcharan puts it, “idealism without political understanding amounts to amateurism”. The UN needs to understand that conducting an official inquiry that is heavily constrained by a lack of time, resources, scope, and competing political factors is nothing but counterproductive. It fails to address the ongoing issues in Sri Lanka, it will never be fully comprehensive and credible, and it will do little to bring justice to any of those involved in alleged war crimes. What it will do however, is erode the credibility the UN has in dealing with human rights abuses. It will also give the impression that the international community has done what it can, or what it is prepared to do, which sends terrible signals to both victims and perpetrators of the alleged atrocities in the country.

Sri Lanka is a case where the UN should take a more indirect role in investigating the reports of war crimes and human rights abuses by working out of the direct spotlight of the Sri Lankan government until enough evidence is collected to prepare a compelling argument to try individuals in the International Criminal Court. Developing contacts and collecting witness statements takes time and resources, both of which the UN is clearly not willing to provide. What they can provide then is expertise and assistance to local and regional efforts to see justice through. The UN has to understand when it should take the lead and when it should instead coordinate or aid other efforts. In Sri Lanka this decision should be a simple one, especially in light of the fact that the current ruling government will likely refuse to allow the UN inquiry to even enter the country.


One thought on “UN Inquiry Fails Before It Begins – Paul Fry”

  1. It is the failure of implementing human rights and ideals universally because of, as you mentioned, factors such as lack or time and resources, that the UNHRC possesses. You bring up a good point about how the UN should take time collecting evidence in the Sri Lanka case to make a better argument to try violators. However, I believe that this can be viewed as a fault of the UNHRC as well. The Sri Lanka reading brought up how these inquiries focus on the past instead of current, ongoing atrocities. Their role in these cases seems to be more of an international shaming/accusatory one than a preventive force of human rights violations. The UN and their policy/action chains on human rights violations seems to dependent on the past, that it seems to perpetuate these atrocities to some extent. From a critical point of view in Monday’s reading of “How is the ICC suppose to work?,” the measures and means of the ICC can encourage human rights abuses by raising the benefit of continuing the abuse until they are put into exile. This reliance on “after the fact,” rather than the UN taking on more preventive measures seems to explain the stagnation of universal human rights compliance.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s